A long time ago I was riding around Beirut with my friend Hanan and her daughter Lina in a borrowed cabriolet. The summer evening was sticky, the humidity almost unbearable, and the sounds of the partying, young rich in Downtown far away.
“Dance, Lina!”, Hanan exclaimed, and Lina started shaking her chubby little body, standing up on Hanan´s lap.
Hanan danced along with her while sitting down in the front seat, snapping her fingers. Lina shaking her head so that her short curls bounced made Hanan laugh. Lina’s silliness was contagious.
We had hung out for a few weeks, and Hanan was soon to go back to what she called home. She didn’t miss Lebanon; it was just a place she visited sometimes from her residence in the Gulf.
“I didn’t think of anything but leaving”, she said once about growing up.
She hadn’t seen much of Lebanon anyhow; mostly her parents’ house and the public school where she failed most courses. Still, she had seen more of the country than her own mother, who usually refused to step out of the house, preferring unhappiness and her prescription pills.
Whatever Hanan had tried to do beforehand seemed to have failed her: moving away from her family, starting a job in the beauty industry, becoming independent. Getting married, moving abroad and having a baby, was the start of her own life.
“Ice-cream!” Hanan said as the car approached one of the many sweet stands, and Lina jumped enthusiastically. Beirut evenings were always sparkling – at least on the surface – and buying sweets was our favorite to top off the evening.
We stopped at the corniche. Hanan pretended to throw Lina into the sea, and Lina laughed. She was used to the outdoors. Every day she and her mom strolled the streets, enjoying malls and playgrounds, had a sandwich for lunch outside. They enjoyed life together, a life new to them both. Even though the sadness in Hanan’s eyes never seemed to fade, I haven’t met many parents that enjoyed parenting as much as she did.
“Ice-cream, mama, bottle!” Hanan practiced her small vocabulary while aimlessly jumping up and down on the corniche.
If Hanan would have lived in any European country, she probably would have ticked several boxes of a social worker’s risk assessment form. Not only was she from a poor, uneducated family, but she would also earn the labels of adolescent parent, victim of violence, lack of family support. All these factors must be an equation for bad parenting – right? But during those sticky, hot weeks in July, Hanan taught me that things are not always as one might think.
That summer, Hanan would tell her family in the village that she was going to stay at her in-laws in Beirut, and after they dropped her off, headed over to my place. The little studio I rented had two single beds; we put them together, I tucked a large blanket over the two and the three of us shared the improvised double bed with Lina in the middle. I still remember Lina kicking me in my head as she was sleeping, happily taking over the whole bed.
We created some memories those weeks.
“Can you babysit?” she asked her in-laws, and they agreed; they loved Lina and were generous, kind people.
And off we went; I brought Hanan to an expat party, she took me to Bay Rock café to smoke sheesha.
But most of all, we often broke night talking on my balcony. What she told me those nights is private, that stays between us. But I blamed myself afterwards, when Hanan abruptly stopped being in touch. Because I know I tend to ask too many questions.
Did I dig up too many painful memories that she would have been better off not being in touch with? Did I do wrong, jumpstarting deep buried emotions? Was it wrong to tell her she deserved a better life?
I knew something was not right, that I maybe had brought up too much. Because upon her return to the Gulf, she was devastated. She called me crying.
“What’s wrong?” I asked, afraid something bad had happened.
“I miss you.”
She cried about everything she had been through, everything we had talked about that she hadn’t told anyone before. It was like Pandora’s box had been opened. Maybe it would have been better to keep it closed.
I have had some memorable evenings during my years abroad, but if there is one I could return to, it would be riding around Beirut in a borrowed cabriolet with Hanan. Because there’s a magic in seeing a mother breaking dysfunctional patterns, showing her daughter true love when she had never experienced one herself. Since I became a parent myself, Hanan continues to amaze me. How she could put so much love and strength into motherhood where many others, more fortunate, cannot.
And she’s not the only one I’ve met, even if she is the one I remember the most. Many mothers are parenting in war zones; parenting other people’s kids; doing the best they can not to transfer the traumas they’ve been through to the children they care for. Unfortunately, these mothers are the ones that rarely get the appreciation they deserve for it. No flowers on Mother’s Day for giving love in impossible situations. They’re often mistrusted, questioned. I don’t believe anyone thanked Hanan for her job; her own family certainly never did.
This post is for all the mothers out there, who are doing the best that they can with whatever little they were handed.
Hanan, if you see this, this flower here is for you.
(please note: not their real names)








